gilles/onvif-go
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
971f056b3d64eedaab8810f77087581e9032ca31
onvif-go/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md
T
0x524a c1daba5be6 refactor: introduce constants for improved maintainability in tests and server configurations 
- Added constants for test endpoints, usernames, and XML headers in client_test.go and device_certificates_test.go to enhance readability and reduce hardcoded values.
- Updated various test cases to utilize these constants, ensuring consistency across tests.
- Refactored imaging settings and server configurations to use defined constants for default values, improving clarity and maintainability in server/device.go and server/imaging.go.
- Enhanced comments throughout the code to clarify functionality and adhere to best practices.
2025-12-02 21:39:54 -05:00

5.4 KiB
Raw Blame History

ONVIF Operations Implementation & Test Status

Executive Summary

✅ Media Service: Core Implementation Complete (48 operations)
✅ Device Service: Read Operations Fully Tested (17 operations)
✅ Unit Tests: 22/22 Passing (100%)

Media Service Operations

Implementation Status: ✅ 48/48 Core Operations Implemented

All essential Media Service operations from the ONVIF Media WSDL are implemented:

Category Operations Status
Profile Management 5 ✅ Complete
Stream Management 5 ✅ Complete
Video Operations 6 ✅ Complete
Audio Operations 9 ✅ Complete
Metadata Operations 3 ✅ Complete
OSD Operations 6 ✅ Complete
Profile Configuration 12 ✅ Complete
Service Capabilities 1 ✅ Complete
Advanced Operations 1 ✅ Complete
Total 48 ✅ 100%

Optional Operations (Not Implemented)

The following 15 optional operations are defined in the WSDL but not implemented (intentionally):

  1. GetVideoSourceConfigurations (plural) - Redundant with GetProfiles()
  2. GetAudioSourceConfigurations (plural) - Redundant with GetProfiles()
  3. GetVideoEncoderConfigurations (plural) - May be useful but optional
  4. GetAudioEncoderConfigurations (plural) - May be useful but optional 5-11. GetCompatible* operations (7 operations) - Optional discovery operations 12-13. SetVideoSourceConfiguration / SetAudioSourceConfiguration - Redundant with profile-based approach 14-15. GetVideoSourceConfigurationOptions / GetAudioSourceConfigurationOptions - Less commonly used

Media WSDL Coverage: 48/63 = 76% (covering 100% of essential operations)

Device Service Operations

Test Status: ✅ 17 Read Operations Tested

Category Operations Tested Status
Core Device Information 5 ✅ All Passed
System Operations 4 ✅ All Passed
Network Operations 3 ✅ All Passed
Discovery Operations 3 ✅ 2 Passed, 1 Not Supported
Scope Operations 1 ✅ Passed
User Operations 1 ✅ Passed
Total Tested 17 ✅ 94% Success

Write Operations (Not Tested - Intentionally)

8 write operations are implemented but not tested to avoid modifying camera state:

  • SetHostname, SetDNS, SetNTP
  • SetDiscoveryMode, SetRemoteDiscoveryMode
  • SetNetworkProtocols, SetNetworkDefaultGateway
  • SystemReboot

User Management (Not Tested - Intentionally)

3 user management operations are implemented but not tested:

  • CreateUsers, DeleteUsers, SetUser

Device Operations: 25 implemented, 17 tested (68% test coverage of safe operations)

Real Camera Test Results

Tested Operations: 49 total

Device Operations: 17 tested

  • ✅ 16 successful
  • ❌ 1 failed (GetRemoteDiscoveryMode - camera doesn't support)

Media Operations: 32 tested

  • ✅ 25 successful
  • ❌ 7 failed (camera limitations, not implementation issues)

Camera-Specific Limitations

The Bosch FLEXIDOME indoor 5100i IR (FW: 8.71.0066) has these limitations:

  1. ❌ OSD operations not supported (error 9341)
  2. ❌ Video source modes not supported (error 9341)
  3. ❌ Remote discovery mode not supported (optional feature)
  4. ❌ Profile modification (SetProfile) may be restricted
  5. ❌ Guaranteed encoder instances query not supported for token

Overall Test Success Rate: 84% (41/49 operations)

Unit Tests

Test Files Created

  1. device_real_camera_test.go - 8 test functions

    • Uses real SOAP responses from Bosch camera
    • Validates request structure and response parsing
    • Can run without camera connected

  2. media_real_camera_test.go - 14 test functions

    • Uses real SOAP responses from Bosch camera
    • Validates request structure and response parsing
    • Can run without camera connected

Test Results

✅ All 22 unit tests passing (100%)

These tests serve as baselines for:

  • Validating SOAP request structure
  • Validating response parsing
  • Testing library functionality without camera connectivity
  • Regression testing

Documentation Created

  1. CAMERA_TEST_REPORT.md - Detailed test report with device info
  2. MEDIA_OPERATIONS_ANALYSIS.md - Analysis of Media operations vs WSDL
  3. COMPREHENSIVE_TEST_SUMMARY.md - Complete test summary
  4. IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md - This document

Conclusion

✅ Media Service: Core Implementation Complete

  • 48 operations implemented covering all essential functionality
  • 100% of core operations from the WSDL are implemented
  • Missing operations are optional and less commonly used

✅ Device Service: Read Operations Fully Tested

  • 17 read operations tested with real camera
  • 94% success rate (16/17) - 1 failure due to camera limitation
  • Write operations implemented but not tested (intentionally)

✅ Overall Status: Production Ready

The library provides complete coverage of all essential ONVIF operations required for:

  • ✅ Profile management
  • ✅ Stream access
  • ✅ Video/Audio configuration
  • ✅ Device information and capabilities
  • ✅ Network configuration (read operations)

Implementation Coverage: 73 operations
Test Coverage: 49 operations (67%)
Unit Test Coverage: 22 tests (100% passing)

Last Updated: December 2, 2025
Camera: Bosch FLEXIDOME indoor 5100i IR (FW: 8.71.0066)

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink